|
We Cured Our Son's Autism
By Karyn Seroussi
Copyright © 2000 Karyn Seroussi
When the doctors said our son would be severely disabled for life, we set
out to prove them wrong.
When the psychologist examining our 18-month-old son told me that she
thought Miles had autism, my heart began to pound. I didn't know exactly
what the word meant, but I knew it was bad. Wasn't autism some type of
mental illness -- perhaps juvenile schizophrenia? Even worse, I vaguely
remembered hearing that this disorder was caused by emotional trauma during
childhood. In an instant, every illusion of safety in my world seemed to
vanish. Our pediatrician had referred us to the psychologist in August 1995
because Miles didn't seem to understand anything we said. He'd developed
perfectly normally until he was 15 months old, but then he stopped saying
the words he'd learned -- cow, cat, dance -- and started disappearing into
himself. We figured his chronic ear infections were responsible for his
silence, but within three months, he was truly in his own world.
Suddenly, our happy little boy hardly seemed to recognize us or his
3-year-old sister. Miles wouldn't make eye contact or even try to
communicate by pointing or gesturing. His behavior became increasingly
strange: He'd drag his head across the floor, walk on his toes (very common
in autistic children), make odd gurgling sounds, and spend long periods of
time repeating an action, such as opening and closing doors or filling and
emptying a cup of sand in the sandbox. He often screamed inconsolably,
refusing to be held or comforted. And he developed chronic diarrhea.
As I later learned, autism -- or autistic spectrum disorder, as doctors now
call it -- is not a mental illness. It is a developmental disability thought
to be caused by an anomaly in the brain. The National Institutes of Health
estimates that as many as 1 in 500 children are affected. But according to
several recent studies, the incidence is rapidly rising: In Florida, for
example, the number of autistic children has increased nearly 600 percent in
the last ten years. Nevertheless, even though it is more common than Down
syndrome, autism remains one of the least understood developmental
disorders.
We were told that Miles would almost definitely grow up to be severely
impaired. He would never be able to make friends, have a meaningful
conversation, learn in a regular classroom without special help, or live
independently. We could only hope that with behavioral therapy, we might be
able to teach him some of the social skills he'd never grasp on his own. I
had always thought that the worst thing that could happen to anyone was to
lose a child. Now it was happening to me but in a perverse, inexplicable
way. Instead of condolences, I got uncomfortable glances, inappropriately
cheerful reassurances, and the sense that some of my friends didn't want to
return my calls.
After Miles' initial diagnosis, I spent hours in the library, searching for
the reason he'd changed so dramatically. Then I came across a book that
mentioned an autistic child whose mother believed that his symptoms had been
caused by a "cerebral allergy" to milk. I'd never heard of this, but the
thought lingered in my mind because Miles drank an inordinate amount of milk
-- at least half a gallon a day.
I also remembered that a few months earlier, my mother had read that many
kids with chronic ear infections are allergic to milk and wheat. "You should
take Miles off those foods and see if his ears clear up," she said. "Milk,
cheese, pasta, and Cheerios are the only foods he'll eat," I insisted. "If I
took them away, he'd starve."
Then I realized that Miles' ear infections had begun when he was 11 months
old, just after we had switched him from soy formula to cow's milk. He'd
been on soy formula because my family was prone to allergies, and I'd read
that soy might be better for him. I had breast-fed until he was 3 months
old, but he didn't tolerate breast milk very well -- possibly because I was
drinking lots of milk. There was nothing to lose, so I decided to eliminate
all the dairy products from his diet. What happened next was nothing short
of miraculous. Miles stopped screaming, he didn't spend as much time
repeating actions, and by the end of the first week, he pulled on my hand
when he wanted to go downstairs. For the first time in months, he let his
sister hold his hands to sing "Ring Around a Rosy."
Two weeks later, a month after we'd seen the psychologist, my husband and I
kept our appointment with a well-known developmental pediatrician to confirm
the diagnosis of autism. Dr. Susan Hyman gave Miles a variety of tests and
asked a lot of questions. We described the changes in his behavior since
he'd stopped eating dairy products. Finally, Dr. Hyman looked at us sadly.
"I'm sorry," the specialist said. "Your son is autistic. I admit the milk
allergy issue is interesting, but I just don't think it could be responsible
for Miles' autism or his recent improvement."
We were terribly disheartened, but as each day passed, Miles continued to
get better. A week later, when I pulled him up to sit on my lap, we made eye
contact and he smiled. I started to cry -- at last he seemed to know who I
was. He had been oblivious to his sister, but now he watched her play and
even got angry when she took things away from him. Miles slept more soundly,
but his diarrhea persisted. Although he wasn't even 2 yet, we put him in a
special-ed nursery school three mornings a week and started an intensive
one-on-one behavioral and language program that Dr. Hyman approved of. I'm
a natural skeptic and my husband is a research scientist, so we decided to
test the hypothesis that milk affected Miles' behavior. We gave him a couple
of glasses one morning, and by the end of the day, he was walking on his
toes, dragging his forehead across the floor, making strange sounds, and
exhibiting the other bizarre behaviors we had almost forgotten. A few weeks
later, the behaviors briefly returned, and we found out that Miles had eaten
some cheese at nursery school. We became completely convinced that dairy
products were somehow related to his autism.
I wanted Dr. Hyman to see how well Miles was doing, so I sent her a video of
him playing with his father and sister. She called right away. "I'm simply
floored," she told me. "Miles has improved remarkably. Karyn, if I hadn't
diagnosed him myself, I wouldn't have believed that he was the same child."
I had to find out whether other kids had had similar experiences. I bought a
modem for my -- not standard in 1995 -- and discovered an autism support
group on the Internet. A bit embarrassed, I asked, "Could my child's autism
be related to milk?" The response was overwhelming. Where had I been?
Didn't I know about Karl Reichelt in Norway? Didn't I know about Paul
Shattock in England? These researchers had preliminary evidence to validate
what parents had been reporting for almost 20 years: Dairy products
exacerbated the symptoms of autism.
My husband, who has a Ph.D. in chemistry, got copies of the journal articles
that the parents had mentioned on-line and went through them all carefully.
As he explained it to me, it was theorized that a subtype of children with
autism break down milk protein (casein) into peptides that affect the brain
in the same way that hallucinogenic drugs do. A handful of scientists, some
of whom were parents of kids with autism, had discovered compounds
containing opiates -- a class of substances including opium and heroin -- in
the urine of autistic children. The researchers theorized that either these
children were missing an enzyme that normally breaks down the peptides into
a digestible form, or the peptides were somehow leaking into the bloodstream
before they could be digested.
In a burst of excitement, I realized how much sense this made. It explained
why Miles developed normally for his first year, when he drank only soy
formula. It would also explain why he had later craved milk: Opiates are
highly addictive. What's more, the odd behavior of autistic children has
often been compared to that of someone hallucinating on LSD. My husband
also told me that the other type of protein being broken down into a toxic
form was gluten -- found in wheat, oats, rye, and barley, and commonly added
to thousands of packaged foods. The theory would have sounded farfetched to
my scientific husband if he hadn't seen the dramatic changes in Miles
himself and remembered how Miles had self-limited his diet to foods
containing wheat and dairy. As far as I was concerned, there was no question
that the gluten in his diet would have to go. Busy as I was, I would learn
to cook gluten-free meals. People with celiac disease are also
gluten-intolerant, and I spent hours on-line gathering information.
Within 48 hours of being gluten-free, 22-month-old Miles had his first solid
stool, and his balance and coordination noticeably improved. A month or two
later, he started speaking -- "zawaff" for giraffe, for example, and "ayashoo"
for elephant. He still didn't call me Mommy, but he had a special smile for
me when I picked him up from nursery school. However, Miles' local doctors
-- his pediatrician, neurologist, geneticist, and gastroenterologist --
still scoffed at the connection between autism and diet. Even though dietary
intervention was a safe, noninvasive approach to treating autism, until
large controlled studies could prove that it worked, most of the medical
community would have nothing to do with it.
So my husband and I decided to become experts ourselves. We began attending
autism conferences and phoning and e-mailing the European researchers. I
also organized a support group for other parents of autistic children in my
community. Although some parents weren't interested in exploring dietary
intervention at first, they often changed their mind after they met Miles.
Not every child with autism responded to the diet, but eventually there were
about 50 local families whose children were gluten- and casein-free with
exciting results. And judging by the number of people on Internet support
lists, there were thousands of children around the world responding well to
this diet.
Fortunately, we found a new local pediatrician who was very supportive, and
Miles was doing so well that I nearly sprang out of bed each morning to see
the changes in him. One day, when Miles was 2 1/2, he held up a toy dinosaur
for me to see. "Wook, Mommy, issa Tywannosauwus Wex!" Astonished, I held out
my trembling hands. "You called me Mommy!" I said. He smiled and gave me a
long hug.
By the time Miles turned 3, all his doctors agreed that his autism had been
completely cured. He tested at eight months above his age level in social,
language, self-help, and motor skills, and he entered a regular preschool
with no special-ed supports. His teacher told me that he was one of the most
delightful, verbal, participatory children in the class. Today, at almost 6,
Miles is among the most popular children in his first-grade class. He's
reading at a fourth-grade level, has good friends, and recently acted out
his part in the class play with flair. He is deeply attached to his older
sister, and they spend hours engaged in the type of imaginative play that is
never seen in kids with autism. My worst fears were never realized. We are
terribly lucky.
But I imagined all the other parents who might not be fortunate enough to
learn about the diet. So in 1997, I started a newsletter and international
support organization called Autism Network for Dietary Intervention (ANDI),
along with another parent, Lisa Lewis, author of Special Diets for Special
Kids (Future Horizons, 1998). We've gotten hundreds of letters and e-mails
from parents worldwide whose kids use the diet successfully. Although it's
best to have professional guidance when implementing the diet, sadly, most
doctors are still skeptical.
As I continue to study the emerging research, it has become increasingly
clear to me that autism is a disorder related to the immune system. Most
autistic children I know have several food allergies in addition to milk and
wheat, and nearly all the parents in our group have or had at least one
immune-related problem: thyroid disease, Crohn's disease, celiac disease,
rheumatoid arthritis, chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, or allergies.
Autistic children are probably genetically predisposed to immune-system
abnormalities, but what triggers the actual disease?
Many of the parents swore that their child's autistic behavior began at 15
months, shortly after the child received the MMR (measles, mumps, rubella)
vaccine. When I examined such evidence as photos and videotapes to see
exactly when Miles started to lose his language and social skills, I had to
admit that it had coincided with his MMR -- after which he had gone to the
emergency room with a temperature of 106°F and febrile seizures. Recently, a
small study was published by British researcher Andrew Wakefield, M.D.,
linking the measles portion of the vaccine to damage in the small intestine
-- which might help explain the mechanism by which the hallucinogenic
peptides leak into the bloodstream. If the MMR vaccine is indeed found to
play a role in triggering autism, we must find out whether some children are
at higher risk and therefore should not be vaccinated or should be
vaccinated at a later age.
Another new development is giving us hope: Researchers at Johnson and
Johnson's Ortho Clinical Diagnostics division -- my husband among them --
are now studying the abnormal presence of peptides in the urine of autistic
children. My hope is that eventually a routine diagnostic test will be
developed to identify children with autism at a young age and that when some
types of autism are recognized as a metabolic disorder, the gluten and
dairy-free diet will move from the realm of alternative medicine into the
mainstream.
The word autism, which once meant so little to me, has changed my life
profoundly. It came to my house like a monstrous, uninvited guest but
eventually brought its own gifts. I've felt twice blessed -- once by the
amazing good fortune of reclaiming my child and again by being able to help
other autistic children who had been written off by their doctors and
mourned by their parents.
Adapted from the book Unraveling the Mystery of Autism and Pervasive
Developmental Disorder: A Mother's Story of Research and Recovery by Karyn
Seroussi.
http://curezone.com/books/amazon/book.asp?ID=449
For more info, contact:
The Autism Network for Dietary Intervention (ANDI)
Fax 609-737-8453
http://www.autismndi.com/
Publishes ANDI News, a newsletter containing recipes, research updates, and
articles by parents and physicians.

It's The Law - Rat Poison Must Be Added to Milk
http://www.notmilk.com/ratpoison.html
In 1932, Title 21 Code of Federal Regulations required that 400 units of rat
poison be added to every quart of milk sold in America. I receive over 2,000
letters each day, but one letter (from Dr. John Unruh Unruh@aol.com),
written in jest, contained a remarkable fact. "Dear Robert, I do not know
how you find this stuff but you continue to pile on the evidence as to why
milk equals rat poison. Keep up the good work." Dear Dr. Unruh, Your
"rat-poison" metaphor is quite close to the truth.
A brochure produced by the Ministry of Environment in Victoria, British
Columbia, Canada, reveals the rat-posion link:
"SAFE AND SENSIBLE PEST CONTROL"
The brochure represents a series of "safe and sensible" pest control
measures, according to the Canadian Health Minister. Canadian health
officials believe that Vitamin D-3 is the most effective and ecologically
sound method of dealing with rat and mouse infestation. Information on milk
cartons reveal that two ingredients fill the container: Milk and Vitamin
D-3. Vitamin D-3 is used to kill rats! Why is it added to milk for our
children to drink in the name of good health?
According to the Canadian brochure, products containing Vitamin D-3 (calciferol)
kill by vitamin overdose after 3-4 days. The Vitamin D-3 actually mobilizes
excessive amounts of calcium from an animal's bones. And you thought that
Vitamin D-3 in milk helped to absorb calcium. Another dairy industry myth!
Don't try this at home. When the animal dies within your walls, its
putrefying body will add the most unpleasant bouquet to your environment.
The offensive smell may last for months. Many methods of mice and rat
control are discussed. I prefer the most foolproof of methods: Don't let
them eat your food. Store all foods in refrigerators or tamper-proof
containers. With no food supply, mice and rats go elsewhere to dine.
How soon we forget! Children are taught in first grade that Vitamin D is the
"sunshine vitamin." Vitamin D is a steroid hormone and is synthesized in
one's body after skin is exposed to sunlight. Once the body has made enough,
it will produce no more. Too much Vitamin D can be toxic and result in bone
loss.
In 1963, the journal Pediatrics (Volume 31) revealed:
"Consuming as little as 45 micrograms of Vitamin D-3 in young children has
resulted in signs of overdose." (one gallon of milk contains 1600 IU, or 40
micrograms). A study published in the New England Journal of Medicine
(Volume 326, 1992) revealed that of 42 milk samples, only 12% were within
the expected range of Vitamin D content. Testing of 10 samples of infant
formula revealed seven with more that twice the Vitamin D content reported
on the label, one of which had more than four times the label amount.
Robert Cohen http://www.notmilk.com

Milk and Autism
Yesterday's Notmilk column discussed Discover
Magazine's treatment of autism, linking it to milk
and dairy consumption. See:
<http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/notmilk/message/2639
>
I was very much surprised to receive dozens of letters asking for more
information. The phrase "show me real science" was a recurring theme in
those letters. Often times, events are not easily reduced into handy
scientific formulas. I wish that was possible with milk consumption. I could
hand out little white cards to moms every time I witnessed an obnoxious
out-of-control kid in the supermarket. Is there a formula for autism and
milk consumption?
Autism, Milk, & Relativity
Albert Einstein is best known for his Theory of Relativity, E = MC2 (Energy
= mass times the speed of light, squared.) Many can recite the formula. Few
can explain it.
Too many school children are being diagnosed with autism. We live in a world
in which little zombies are on dangerous drugs including Ritalin.
So, for today's column, we've developed a formula to describe what will
result in mid-life crisis for many.
Autism = M + I + D (Autism = mood swings + irritability+ depression)
Eighty percent of cow's milk protein is casein. It has been documented that
casein breaks down in the stomach to produce a morphine-like substance
called casomorphine, an opiate. As early as 1979, Panksepp, et. al.,
observed that casomorphin aggravated the symptoms of autism.(Trends in
Neuroscience, 1979, 2)
In 1988, Gillberg, et. al., produced evidence of elevated levels of
endorphin-like substances in the cerebro-spinal fluid of children with
autism. (Aspects of Autism: Biological Research Gaskell:London, pp. 31-37).
Dr. Kalle Reichelt, University of Oslo, Norway, believes that milk
casomorphins cause learning disorders in 25 percent of children. He writes:
"We therefore by and large treat with a strict diet free of gluten and milk
proteins with reasonably good results. Note: diet must be strict and long
term."
Florida researcher, Robert Cade, M.D., and his colleagues have identified a
milk casomorphin as the probable cause of attention deficit disorder and
autism. They also found Beta-casomorphin-7 in high concentrations in
the blood and urine of patients with either schizophrenia or autism.
(AUTISM, 1999, 3)
Search the Internet and you'll find many anecdotal stories from parents
blaming their children's autism on milk and dairy products.
In May of 1996, Julie Klotter, M.D., wrote in the Townsend Medical Letter:
"In reality, cow's milk, especially processed cow's milk, has been linked to
a variety of health problems, including: mucous production, hemoglobin loss,
childhood diabetes, heart disease, atherosclerosis, arthritis, kidney
stones, mood swings, depression, irritability, and allergies."
Dr. Klotter was primarily concerned with adult reactions to milk opiates and
milk proteins. Of her eleven symptoms, take note of numbers eight, nine, and
ten. Mood swings, irritability, and depression. MID = autism. Cow's milk
opiates are not for human kids, and they're not for human adults. Unless you
wish to display GAB (Goofy Adult Behavior), just say no to all dairy
products.
Warning: addiction to opiates is not pretty. Neither is withdrawal. Your
child will be angry. Scream. Be moody. Turn into a monster. You must be
strong. Milk drinkers are drug addicts. It is no different for milk
chocaholics. Recognize that all dairy products, even organic ones, naturally
contain powerful morphine-like substances.
Robert Cohen
http://www.notmilk.com
i4crob@earthlink.net

Life, love and autism: A tale of one couple's journey
BY MAJA BECKSTROM
Knight Ridder Newspapers
ST. PAUL, Minn. - (KRT) - April and Eric Schnell refer to their son's
life up to age 3 as the dark years. After birth, Tim was sickly. As a
toddler, he rarely smiled and didn't return his parents' affection. At
age 3, he spoke only 20 words.
But mostly, Tim cried. He cried and gagged when he touched gravel or
grass or any rough surface. He cried when the phone rang, prompting the
Schnells to switch off the ringer for good. He shrieked during haircuts.
At night, his parents took turns checking into a motel or sleeping on the
living room couch with earplugs.
At a certain point, April recalled, "It just hit me, there is something
really, really wrong."
By age 3 1/2, Tim had been diagnosed with autism. The neurological
disorder is characterized by a need for routine, an obsession with
patterns or numbers and difficulty communicating and picking up on the
nuances of social interaction.
Tim is one of the 5,900 Minnesotans under age 21 who has been diagnosed
with an autism spectrum disorder, a term describing autism and related
disorders such as Aspergers.
In recent years, the number of children on the spectrum has shot up
alarmingly. In Minnesota in 2002, the rate of autism in 6- to 11-year-old
children was 17 times what it was a decade earlier.
Epidemiologists suspect the jump is the result of a broadened definition,
better diagnosis and greater public awareness. But they admit there might
simply be more autistic children than there used to be.
While the cause of autism remains a mystery, its symptoms can be
alleviated with intensive early treatment. The Schnells are among a
growing number of parents who have tried conventional therapies and also
have embraced unproven, experimental methods. They have spent thousands
of dollars and countless hours seeking help for their son.
The Schnells are among the lucky ones. Tim has miraculously, his parents
say, improved. At age 7, he's a curious, lively first-grader with intense
brown eyes and a playful smile. His latest report card showed he's
keeping up with his peers and doing especially well in language arts.
This is the path his family took.
When April Schnell looks back at Tim's first years, she now recognizes
all the warning signs of autism. But at the time, she tried to convince
herself that her first-born child was colicky or developing slowly. Deep
down, she dreaded that she was doing something wrong.
At their Early Childhood Family Education class, Tim cried hysterically
whenever April left the room. When the parents and children were
together, he retreated to a corner to play with the same Fisher-Price
parking garage week after week. The class instructor told April that she
thought the family's nanny might be abusing him.
As a toddler, Tim was uninterested in other children. On a rare play date
at a playground, he spent the entire time fussing with a garbage can lid.
At a pool party, he was only interested in opening and closing the gate.
Like other parents with autistic children, the Schnells felt isolated.
"Other parents don't get it," April said. "They say, 'Oh I had a bad day,
too.' And you'll think, 'No, you can't say that being a mother has been
the worst experience of your life.'"
Eric Schnell agreed.
"There is this intensity of experience that is really hard to describe,"
he said. "When your kid is screaming nonstop, you're torn between this
incredible love for this child who you created and then made the promise
to take care of ... and, well ... loathing. I mean just like you've been
invaded."
A turning point came just after Tim turned 2. Eric and April baby-sat for
a friend and saw how glaring Tim's delays were compared with the other
child. Eric scheduled an evaluation. Tim scored in the lowest 1 percent.
"It was crushing," Eric said.
The Schnells were referred to the Special Children's Center in Hudson,
Wis., where Tim was diagnosed with sensory integration dysfunction, a
condition that often accompanies autism and is characterized by either
extreme sensitivity or a seeming numbness to touch, movement, sights or
sounds.
The diagnosis explained some of Tim's odd behavior. He was so sensitive
to noise that he once woke with a start to the sound of an icicle
dripping on the pavement below his window. He was so sensitive to visual
stimulation that he screamed when his parents turned on the colored
Christmas lights.
Tim started speech therapy, physical therapy and occupational therapy six
hours a week, a regimen that lasted four years. To improve his sense of
gravity, therapists coaxed him onto trampolines. To desensitize his skin,
he played in plastic tubs filled with rice or noodles. Eric and April
were taught to brush his entire body with a firm-bristled brush.
Eric felt relief. Relief that they finally had some answers. Relief that
they weren't crazy. That they weren't alone. And that Tim's problems
weren't as severe as those of other children they met.
But April was losing hope. The worst moment came one day at the clinic.
Tim was hysterical, and to calm and control him, April had to lie on top
of him. Lying there, she said she realized that from the minute she woke
up in the morning until she closed her eyes at night, her life was held
hostage by her damaged son.
The Schnells stuck with therapy, despite seeing little change in Tim.
Then, about six months into his regimen, the center's director mentioned
that other families had seen improvements after removing dairy products
from their children's diets. So, the Schnells tried that.
A couple days later, for the first time in his life, Tim slept through
the night. He was 3 years old. Like many children with autism, Tim had
suffered from gastrointestinal problems. Those, too, cleared up.
"Suddenly he became more verbal," said April. "And, he was willing to
take more risks."
That was the good news. But also around that time, Tim received his
formal diagnosis of autism. Though the Schnells had begun to suspect it,
actually hearing it was devastating.
The word autism conjures up images of "Rain Man" or a child rocking in a
corner. The stereotypes only sometimes match reality. While a fundamental
difficulty in communicating lies at the heart of the disorder, autistic
behaviors vary widely. One child might have a huge vocabulary while
another might not speak at all. One might be mentally retarded while
another might be brilliant.
Estimates of its prevalence range from 1 in 160 to 1 in 500. It is four
times more prevalent in boys. Until the 1960s, it was thought to be
caused by detached and uncaring "refrigerator" mothers.
Today, experts believe it is linked to defective genes. Some theorize
that environmental factors, such as pollution or the mercury used in the
production of childhood vaccines, can trigger autism in susceptible
children. A recent study in the New England Journal of Medicine found no
link to childhood vaccines, but many, including the Schnells, suspect
they play some role.
Amid the swirl of competing theories, desperate parents swap anecdotes
about the children who somehow get better. They cite studies about the
benefits of intensive behavior-modification therapy and talk about the
severely autistic child who, after treatment, entered mainstream
kindergarten. There are books written by parents who have pursued
unorthodox treatments and gotten results.
Those stories rekindled hope in April Schnell. By now, the couple had a
second son, Matthew. Tim was almost 5, and April had quit her job to
manage and research his treatment. She was especially intrigued by
stories of children who improved after radically changing their diets and
starting vitamin therapies.
First, she and Eric had to overcome their misgivings about trying
treatments not endorsed by the medical establishment.
"It's scary," said April. "You feel you're going against the mainstream.
If this really works, why isn't this more well known? I asked my
pediatrician to look over this stuff to see if she saw any red flags. She
said, 'I can't tell you to do this or not to do this.'
"You wonder, are we playing God here? Is our son a chemistry lab? What if
we did some harm to him?"
Eric was even more skeptical and still is.
"We've had to think long and hard about our roles as parents," said Eric.
"On the one hand, it is our responsibility to try everything we can to
help our child. On the other hand, we didn't want to keep viewing our son
as a project, as a thing that is broken and needs fixing.
"I mean, there comes a point when you just have to love your son, however
he is."
The first step was relatively easy, at least ethically. April and Eric
moved the entire family to a dairy-free, wheat-free and soy-free diet. In
place of cow's milk, they used milk made from potato starch. They amassed
recipes for meals like tapioca flour waffles. They pored over labels and
called food manufacturers, tossing out things like their favorite
pepperoni that contained trace amounts of wheat.
Then, they learned about a Chicago clinic that specializes in treating
behavioral disorders, such as autism and ADHD, by trying to restore the
body's chemical balance.
The nonprofit Pfeiffer Treatment Center made news in 2001, when founder
and director Bill Walsh reported at the American Psychiatric
Association's meeting that autism might be linked to a defective protein
called metallothionein, which plays a crucial role in helping the body
purge toxic metals, such as mercury and lead.
The Schnells had Tim's blood, urine and hair evaluated. Like other
autistic children, he tested high for copper and toxic metals and low in
zinc, calcium, magnesium and a range of vitamins.
They put him on supplements. They also started him on something called a
metallothionein promoter, a cocktail of 14 amino acids, vitamins and
minerals designed to enhance the body's ability to create its own
metallothionein protein.
Walsh's theory remains unproven and isn't widely accepted by the medical
establishment. But some autism experts see hope in his research and
results. More than 1,500 children have been treated with the promoter,
and a preliminary study of the first 50 patients found that nine out of
10 who stuck with the treatment showed improvement.
In two years, Tim, now 7, has made dramatic progress. The week he went
off wheat, he came home from school and told his mother he wanted to show
her something. He had never tried to draw her into his world before. He
became more affectionate. His language improved. His tantrums subsided.
The Schnells credit not only the Pfeiffer treatment and diet but also
Tim's therapies, including 1 1/2 years in a social skills program at
Fraser Child and Family Center in Minneapolis. He learned to name
feelings, stood inside a hula-hoop to learn about personal space and
practiced taking turns in games.
In 2002, Tim had improved so much that he was given a new diagnosis of
Aspergers, which has been described by one expert as "having a dash of
autism."
"He made some really nice gains," said Pat Pulice, director of Fraser's
autism program. "Technically, you don't move from one diagnosis to
another. But his language had increased, and his verbal skills were
solidly in the average range. What specifically caused the change is hard
to say."
Pulice figures about 10 percent of the children in Fraser's autism
program are on a diet like Tim's, and she can't venture a guess as to how
many might be trying the vitamin and promoter therapy. But she cautioned
that not every child shows improvement.
"I've seen cases where it's made a big difference," she said. "But
unfortunately there isn't a lot of scientific information about which
kids might respond. So, it ends up being the parents' judgment about
whether to try it."
It also is expensive. The Schnells say they could not have afforded it
without the nearly $60,000 they have received from a state program
designed to keep disabled children out of institutional care and that
reimburses parents for part of the expense of treatment, respite care and
other essentials.
On a recent night, the Schnells gathered around the dinner table for
tacos, minus cheese and sour cream. Tim sat across from his 3-year-old
brother. He said he wanted to go see the Arthur exhibit at the Children's
Museum and instantly provided its closing date. Like many children with
Aspergers, he has a remarkable memory and an affinity for facts and
numbers.
After he is excused, his voice suddenly squeaks through the intercom in
the next room. "Attention!" he calls out. "I got my report card today."
"That's great Timmer," calls out his dad. "How did you do?"
"We'll never see unless we open it," said the disembodied voice.
His parents clear a space on the table to pore over the papers. Tim
attends first grade at a Roseville charter school with a large percentage
of children with disabilities. His first report card shows average scores
and a "satisfactory plus" in language arts.
"There were times when we didn't know if he would talk," said Eric,
starting to choke up. "So this is ... well ... momentous."
He turns to Tim, who is squirming with delight. "You got some pluses,
Wow! You must be feeling pretty proud of yourself."
Not all the signs of autism have disappeared. Tim acts young for his age.
His favorite cartoons, like "Berenstain Bears," are ones that usually
appeal to younger children.
He has a diagnosis of a nonverbal learning disability, which means he has
trouble summing things up or recognizing relevant detail. He can recite
snatches of dialogue verbatim from television shows, for example, but he
can't tell you the plot.
He has motor and coordination difficulties that make it hard for him to
write. His need for routine is less but still strong. He takes the same
route through McDonald's Playland every time and always lines up his toy
cars the same way.
And like other children with an autism spectrum disorder, he has trouble
reading social cues. One day last year, he came home from the public
school he attended and told his parents he had poked a boy. The boy had
said he would put Tim "on the floor." Unable to make sense of the
exchange, Tim asked his parents: "Isn't that funny?"
His parents have overheard other children say they don't want to play
with Tim or don't like him. It breaks their hearts because they know as
he gets older, social interactions will become more difficult.
Inevitably, the Schnells worry about the future.
"Will he be able to support himself?" said Eric. "Will he and his brother
keep the relationship they have now? Will he need someone to take care of
him when he is older? I want to hope for the best and plan for the
worst."
For now, they try to take it one day at a time. And celebrate the son
they feel they are getting to know.
"Sometimes, I tell myself he's making up for lost time," said April.
"Before, he never came running over to me to say, 'Mama! Mama! Come be
with me!' He didn't like to be held or hugged. But now, Tim will come and
lie in my bed and take my arm and put it around him. And he'll tell me,
'This feels so good Mama.'
"I don't know how to describe it. It's like being lost in a desert and
being handed a cup of water. I didn't know how much I was missing it
until he started giving it back."
---
© 2004, Saint Paul Pioneer Press (St. Paul, Minn.).

Health Sciences Institute e-Alert
January 21, 2004
Obesity is on the rise... among children as well as adults. But a new
study shows that parents may be able to help obese children control their
weight by increasing one important mineral in their diet.
The good news is that this mineral is easy to come by and may also be a
key nutritional element in helping adults lose weight, too. The
not-so-good news is that advice on the best way to get this mineral is a
subject of controversy and confusion.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Following the kids
--------------------------------------------------------------
Previous studies have shown that an intake of dietary calcium among
adults may be associated with lower amounts of body fat. With childhood
obesity becoming a serious problem in most Western countries, researchers
at the University of Tennessee (UT) designed a study to find out if
calcium levels would have a beneficial effect on children's body fat.
Researchers enrolled a total of 52 children. The group was evenly divided
between boys and girls, and each child began the study two months after
birth. All of the children were followed for eight years, with regular
monitoring of weight, height, dietary intake and other related variables.
Body fat was assessed with an x-ray technique called absorptiometry,
which measures density.
When the data was compiled, a result that surprised no one was an
association between higher body fat and the consumption of
sugar-sweetened soft drinks. Lower body fat was most strongly
associated with two factors: dietary calcium and polyunsaturated
fat intake. Additionally, sufficient calcium intake was associated with
diets that delivered a variety of different foods.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Adults benefit too
--------------------------------------------------------------
As I mentioned above, calcium intake may also provide adults with
benefits for body weight management. Earlier this year, the National
Institutes of Health (NIH) published a review of studies that examined
the correlation of body weight to the intake of supplemental and dietary
calcium. Among the data, researchers found evidence that:
* Subjects who showed the highest level of weight loss also had the
highest intake of calcium
* Subjects with lower calcium intakes generally were found to have
elevated body weight
* Subjects with diets high in dairy and calcium tended to have greater
loss of fat in the trunk area (Frankly, this one surprises me. With
everything we know about dairy products, I think we'll need to see the
results of further studies before we can take this conclusion at face
value.)
The NIH report notes that the studies reviewed were mostly small in
scope, but conclusive enough to justify larger, population-based clinical
trials - especially in light of the growing numbers of Americans
suffering from obesity and other pre-diabetic conditions.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Come and get it
--------------------------------------------------------------
So how should you (and your kids and grandkids) go about getting calcium?
The UT team concluded their study with this advice: "Children should be
strongly encouraged to regularly include
calcium-rich foods and beverages in their diets. And of course,
"calcium-rich beverages" is likely a reference to milk, which is where
the controversy begins.
One of the iconic beliefs of our culture is that milk is good for you,
does a body good, builds strong bones, keeps teeth strong, etc. But as
I've addressed in previous e-Alerts, there are many studies that support
evidence that milk and other dairy products create more health problems
than they solve - especially pasteurized milk which is low on vitamins
and contains traces of antibiotics given to cows.
Fortunately, there are better sources of dietary calcium,
including:
* Half a cup of cooked kale - 100 mg of calcium
* Half a cup of yellow, green, or wax beans - 55 mg
* A medium orange - 55 mg
* Three ounces of salmon - 80 mg
--------------------------------------------------------------
Got magnesium?
--------------------------------------------------------------
If calcium has a downside, it's that the body does a poor job of
absorbing it. In fact, only a small percentage of our calcium intake
(whether from food or supplements) actually makes it into the
bloodstream. But magnesium is known to increase the absorption of
calcium, and many of the food sources of magnesium fit into a
weight-watching diet: leafy green vegetables, whole grains, bananas,
apricots, meat, beans, and nuts.
Phosphorus also promotes good calcium absorption. This is why sunflower
seeds, sesame seeds and figs are some of the best calcium sources around,
because all three deliver calcium, magnesium and phosphorus. In addition,
phosphorus helps develop hard enamel, but studies have shown that the
interior structure of teeth can be weakened when too much calcium and
phosphorus are present without magnesium. And guess what delivers calcium
and phosphorus, but zero magnesium?
Milk.

|
Autism and Malnutrition: The Milk
Connection |
| |
|
By
Linda Carlton
To understand autism we can begin this journey from what we have
learned about how seemingly insignificant dietary changes can affect
newborn primates. In October 1975, three Japanese scientists raised a
group of infant primates. By artificial nursing, these primates were
fed a casein powdered milk formula. When they modified the infant
formula to reduce the content of protein and increased the lactose to
supplement the appropriate number of calories, the primate infants
developed abnormal behaviors such as stereotype rocking, fear,
aggression, head banging and other autistic-like behaviors.
Completely unaware of what they had discovered, the scientists had
induced autism in a clinical setting.
Now, they were aware that by reducing the protein content they
caused the infants to become malnourished. They also observed that
without human contact some infants were much more impaired. They
learned that the infants that received the standard solution were
reared successfully. At that time they concluded that a protein
deficiency had caused a decline in physical and mental growth.
Subsequent studies have supported this, whereby protein deficiency
does cause developmental delay.
Autism Versus Developmental Delay
But it is important to know which symptoms are truly autistic and
which are that of developmental delay. These disorders are often used
interchangeably, but they are very different. For example, hand
flapping is an autistic symptom, but it is not a common
characteristic of developmental delay. In developmental delay
children are often slow to learn, and will quickly fall behind their
peers. The symptoms of these primates were more than just symptoms of
developmental delay--they were symptoms of autism.
The most important information we have about these infant primates
is that the researchers had also increased the lactose content in
their diet. If the quantity of protein matched that of the quantity
of lactose, this might not have occurred, or it might also have
occurred if they had been fed too much protein. The standard formula
given to the infant primates that were reared successfully were given
the same amount of lactose, and what would have been the normal
amount of protein for these size mammals.
Lactose and Autism
Lactose is the key to unraveling what happened to these infants.
Bacteria use lactose, or milk sugar, as a nutrient base.
Bifidobacteria and clostridia use lactose, and they often describe
these strains of bacteria as lactose-fermenting bacteria. One
difference in Bifidobacteria and Clostridia is that only one can
produce significant amounts of ammonia, only one can damage the
intestines. Milk oligosaccharides contain lactose; they are fermented
in the infant colon where they selectively stimulate the growth of
Bifidobacteria. Clostridia are competitors of Bifidobacteria, and
Clostridia produce ammonia. Ammonia and only ammonia produced from
bacteria could have caused the aberrant behaviors.
The infant primates had developed symptoms of autism because there
was protein restriction, milk proteins needed for ammonia
detoxification, and not necessarily just casein. They were fed
lactose and lactose ferments ammonia, producing bacteria. They were
unable to detoxify on a protein-deficient diet. It is a simple
formula:
Protein + Lactose = Normal Development
Low protein + High Lactose = Autism
But protein malnutrition does not equal autism nor does lactose
feeding equal autism. However,
Protein malnutrition + high-lactose feeding + (the unknown
factor) = Autism
There has to be an unknown factor for this to occur, a combination
of things that all relate to one another. The unknown factor can be
found by testing these three variables. We have to review other
information that we have on children with autism to give us the
correct answer to the unknown factor.
A low-protein diet offsets a nitrogen balance to detoxify ammonia,
whereas lactose feeding ferments bacteria. The only variable that
could account for the unknown factor is ammonia. In autism, there are
signs of ammonia detoxification, for example when GABA and nitric
oxide are increased. So instead of developing overt ammonia toxicity,
they are able to detoxify this excess ammonia. As encouraging as this
sounds it still depletes cellular energy. Many parents can recall
'staring spells' as the first behavioral change in a child prior to
autistic regression. This can be the first sign of increased blood
ammonia.
Other symptoms found in children with only minimal increases in
blood ammonia were:
 | Developmental regression |
 | Loss of acquired speech |
 | Stereotype hand movements |
 | Myoclonic seizures |
 | Generalized epileptic discharges |
 | Repetitive behaviors |
 | Sensory dysfunction |
 | Auditory and visual hallucinations
|
Finegold and his colleagues have published three studies on
children with autism. The first study was with the use of
antibiotics. The second study of stool specimens indicated a vast
overpopulation of Clostridia in children with autism. Many physicians
use antibiotics for treatment of elevated blood ammonia to kill the
ammonia-producing bacteria. Antibiotics have produced dramatic
effects in children with autism, however this treatment did
inevitably fail. Experiments with fermented foods after antibiotic
treatments have been somewhat successful in preventing relapsing
Clostridial infections.
Live Bacteria to Temper Immune Response
As many of us already know, treatment with probiotic supplements
at most show only minor, if any, improvement in autistic symptoms.
These can sometimes take weeks or even months to take affect or may
never have any effect. The reason for this is that when probiotic
bacteria are dried and then rehydrated, even with prebiotic
assistance it takes time for these bacteria to reestablish a colony.
When live bacteria are frozen they can re-colonize within 24 hours at
room temperature, but when bacteria are heat-killed they induce an
immune response and their ability to re-colonize is remote. Each time
we consume foods with heat-killed bacteria it produces an immune
response.
Every time we receive a vaccination with heat-killed bacteria or a
heat-killed virus, it produces a similar immune response. Live
bacteria such as that of lactic acid bacteria can temper these immune
responses. The infant primates were fed heat-treated formulas,
Clostridia is an opportunist infection, looking for a chance to
colonize. However, Clostridia is also a natural inhabitant of the
colon. The problem here with heat-treated foods is that you might as
well say they are sterile. If you are feeding sterile foods, they
don't contain bacteria that can form
a colony. So in order to colonize bacteria you have to consume foods
with live bacteria or an opportunist will take that invitation.
Breast-fed babies are colonized naturally by Bifidobacteria.
Babies fed formula develop much more harmful fecal environments.
Preterm infants are especially at risk for Clostridrial infections
because there is usually a delay in breast feeding. In older children
generally pathogenic Clostridial infections develop after antibiotic
treatment, which can destroy the beneficial bacteria derived from the
mother.
Impaired Digestion and Pasteurized Milk
Pasteurized milk causes the impaired digestion of casein and other
proteins found in milk. Malnutrition is caused by either an
insufficient diet or an impaired utilization of foods. Malabsorption
is the impairment of intestinal absorption of nutrients. Some
children with protein-calorie deficiency had abnormal intestinal fat
absorption, and because of this they had an increased uptake of
serotonin in the plasma. One scientific study found
hyperserotoninaemia in 70 percent of their autistic patients. It
should come as no surprise that serotonin uptake inhibitors have had
some success in treating autistic children. The medical literature
supports the realization that protein deficiency causes developmental
delay and even mild increases in ammonia causes oddities in behavior.
Some methods of ammonia detoxification have been suggested with
the use of lactulose, oral lactulose and the drug Tributyrate, which
can scavenge excess ammonia. Lactulose can cause extreme irritability
in children, and perhaps its use with autistic children was abandoned
due to these circumstances.
Impacted Colons and Pasteurized Milk
Children with autism frequently have impacted colons. Clostridia
is notorious for reducing the quantity of water in the colon. Hard
dry stools can cause irritability once stool-softening products are
started. These stools might only be removed by using an enema prior
to beginning any stool-softening treatment. Once the bowels have been
cleared of extremely hard, dry stools, then treatment with stool
softeners can begin.
What we have to consider is the matter of colonizing bacteria. A
healthy colon in a normal infant contains a significant supply of
Bifidobacteira. Pasteurized milk simply putrefies in the colon and
hinders the passage of fecal matter.
Pasteurized milk contains heat-killed bacteria and is unable to
reflourish the colon with host-friendly bacteria--unless
contaminated, it is sterile.
When milk proteins are damaged by heat processing it renders them
indigestible.
Raw milk does not cause constipation. Constipation is caused by
the loss of moisture. Lactose and lactulose add moisture back to the
colon, but clostridia can quickly dry up the feces. Raw milk is
easily digestible by infants, for as long as babies have been born
mothers have been feeding their young casein and other milk proteins.
Clostridia can feed on unabsorbed lactose from the diet. Lactose is
completely hydrolyzed in cheeses made with bifidobacteria.
Autism and Casein-Free Diets
Science cannot support the presumption that a casein-free diet
reduces autistic symptoms. All the literature on casein restriction
indicates this only causes a developmental delay. If an improvement
is seen on a casein-free diet, it is only because of the removal of
free lactose, and the removal of constipating foods.
The very worst thing that you can do to a child coping with
mercury is to wean them off of breast or raw milk. Weaning causes the
hair and blood mercury levels to suddenly drop, and it is re-routed
to the colon for excretion. If the child is constipated, it could
mean real problems.
Now we know three Japanese researchers were able to induce autism
in a clinical setting, with a low-protein, high-lactose, sterilized
formula. The belief that infant-mother separation or the refrigerator
mother causes autistic symptoms continued for many years.
Understanding what happened to these infant primates could have
changed the course of medical history. Unfortunately, two new
theories of what causes autistic symptoms have followed.
Treating Autistic Symptoms
To treat the symptoms of autism, we have to feed our children
foods that they can digest, foods that do not cause constipation,
foods that will give them back the bacterial environment to temper
these inflammatory conditions. And most importantly return to proper
nitrogen-ammonia balance.
Treatment should begin with a healthy diet, high in quality
protein foods such as eggs, meat, milk and cheese and balanced
essential oils. Raw goat's or raw cow's milk may be given. If not
well tolerated, then
cultured raw milk/kefir can be used. Oral, inexpensive butyrate
may be given to both clean the colon and to detoxify ammonia from the
liver and bowels.
To finalize, there are still the issues of treating malabsorption,
the impairment of intestinal absorption of nutrients and abnormal
intestinal fat absorption. To begin nutritional rehabilitation for
your child you will need some help navigating through the complicated
process. Dr. Patricia Kane has treated thousands of children with
autism over the past 25 years who have not only had malnutrition, but
also abnormal intestinal fat absorption. Restoration of digestive
function is critical to absorbing dietary essential fatty acids and
stabilizing the nutrient base.
Japanese scientists in 1975 documented the development of autistic
symptoms and revealed how diet can induce these symptoms. In 2004 we
now have the tools to eradicate the symptoms of autism.

|

Got Migraines?
Fifteen years ago, the journal of Pediatrics (1989;84(4):595-603)
reported:
"Dairy products may play a major role in the development of allergies,
asthma, sleep difficulties, and migraine headaches."

Why Does Cow's Milk Contain Calcium?
Do you wonder why it is that cow's milk contains so much calcium? After
all, cow's do not drink milk. Where then, do they get their calcium? The
answer is that plants (veggies) are loaded with calcium. Cows eat plants.
Humans should, too.
Human breast milk is the perfect formula for baby humans. In her wisdom,
Mother Nature included 33 milligrams of calcium in every 100 grams, or 3
1/2-ounce portion, of human breast milk. At the end of this column are
calcium values for 55 commonly eaten foods. Compare those calcium values
to human breast milk.
The perfect calcium-rich food is hummus. Chick peas (150 mg) + sesame
seeds (1160 mg) will yield a food containing ten times as much calcium as
human breast milk. In order to absorb calcium, the body needs comparable
amounts of another mineral element, magnesium. Magnesium is the center
atom of chlorophyl. Milk and dairy products contain only small amounts of
magnesium. Without the presence of magnesium, the body only absorbs 25
percent of the available dairy calcium content. The remainder of the
calcium spells trouble. Without magnesium, excess calcium is utilized by
the body in injurious ways. The body uses calcium to build the mortar on
arterial walls which becomes atherosclerotic plaques. Excess calcium is
converted by the kidneys into painful stones which grow in size like
pearls in oysters, blocking our urinary tracts. Excess calcium
contributes to arthritis; painful calcium buildup often is manifested as
gout.
Osteoporosis is NOT a problem that should be associated with lack of
calcium intake. Osteoporosis results from calcium loss. The massive
amounts of protein in milk result in a 50 percent loss of calcium in the
urine. In other words, by doubling your protein intake there will be a
loss of 1-1.5 percent in skeletal mass per year in postmenopausal women.
The calcium contained in leafy green vegetables is more easily absorbed
than the calcium in milk, and plant proteins do not result in calcium
loss the same way as do animal proteins.
Human breast milk contains 33 milligrams of calcium per 100-gram portion
and potato chips contain 40 milligrams!
Calcium content of foods (per 100-gram portion) (100 grams equals around
3.5 ounces):
01. Human Breast Milk 33 mg
02. Almonds 234 mg
03. Amaranth 267 mg
04. Apricots (dried) 67 mg
05. Artichokes 51 mg
06. Beans (can: pinto, black) 135 mg
07. Beet greens (cooked) 99 mg
08. Blackeye Peas 55 mg
09. Bran 70 mg
10. Broccoli (raw) 48 mg
11. Brussel Sprouts 36 mg
12. Buckwheat 114 mg
13. Cabbage (raw) 49 mg
14. Carrot (raw) 37 mg
15. Cashew nuts 38 mg
16. Cauliflower (cooked) 42 mg
17. Swiss Chard (raw) 88 mg
18. Chickpeas (garbanzos) 150 mg
19. Collards (raw leaves) 250 mg
20. Cress (raw) 81 mg
21. Dandelion Greens 187 mg
22. Endive 81 mg
23. Escarole 81 mg
24. Figs (dried) 126 mg
25. Filberts (Hazelnuts) 209 mg
26. Kale (raw leaves) 249 mg
27. Kale (cooked leaves) 187 mg
28. Leeks 52 mg
29. Lettuce (lt. green) 35 mg
30. Lettuce (dark green) 68 mg
31. Molasses (dark-213 cal.) 684 mg
32. Mustard Greens (raw) 183 mg
33. Mustard Greens (cooked) 138 mg
34. Okra (raw or cooked) 92 mg
35. Olives 61 mg
36. Oranges (Florida) 43 mg
37. Parsley 203 mg
38. Peanuts (roasted & salted) 74 mg
39. Peas (boiled) 56 mg
40. Pistachio Nuts 131 mg
41. Potato Chips 40 mg
42. Raisins 62 mg
43. Rhubarb (cooked) 78 mg
44. Sauerkraut 36 mg
45. Sesame Seeds 1160 mg
46. Squash (Butternut) 40 mg
47. Soybeans 60 mg
48. Sugar (brown) 85 mg
49. Tofu 128 mg
50. Spinach (raw) 93 mg
51. Sunflower Seeds 120 mg
52. Sweet Potatoes (baked) 40 mg
53. Turnips (cooked) 35 mg
54. Turnip Greens (raw) 246 mg
55. Turnip Greens (boiled) 184 mg
56. Water Cress 151 mg

Conditioning
We are so conditioned into believing that milk gives us calcium that we
can’t imagine it might harm us and cause osteoporosis.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Blood acidity
Keeping our blood at an essentially neutral pH is a top priority for the
body. If our blood were to become too acidic we would die. If the diet
contains a lot of acid forming foods, then the body withdraws calcium
from the bones and uses this alkaline mineral to balance the pH of the
blood. Meat, eggs and fish are the most acid-forming foods. Most fruits
and vegetables yield an alkaline ash, and don't deplete calcium stores.
High protein diets in general, and meat based diets in particular, lead
to a gradual decrease in bone density. World health statistics show that
osteoporosis is most common in exactly those countries where diary
products are con-sumed in the largest quantities - the U.S.A., Finland,
Sweden, and the United Kingdom. 2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
African Women
African Bantu women take in only 350 mg. of calcium per day, compared to
the R.D.A. of 1,200 mg. They bear nine children during their lifetime and
breast feed them for two years. They never have calcium deficiency,
seldom break a bone, and rarely lose a tooth. Their low protein diet
doesn't kick the calcium out of the body. 3 They consume much less
calcium than Americans, and yet are essentially free of osteoporosis. 4
Genetic relatives of the Bantus living in the U.S.A., and eating the
standard American diet, have levels of osteoporosis equal to those of
their white neighbours. 5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eskimos
Eskimos have the highest dietary calcium intake of any people in the
world - more than 2,000 mg. a day 6 - and one of the worlds highest
protein - 250 to 400 grams a day. 7 Native Eskimo people have one of the
very highest rates of osteoporosis in the world. 8
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
References
Robbins, John, Diet for a New America, Stillpoint Publishing, 1987, pages
189-199.
Walker, A., "Calcium Retention in the Adult human Male as Affected by
Protein Intake", Journal of Nutrition, 102:1297, 1972.
Pritikin, N., quoted in Vegetarian Times, Issue 43, pg. 22.
Walker, A., "Osteoporosis and Calcium Deficiency," American Journal of
Clinical Nutrition, 16:327, 1965
Smith, R., "Epidemiologic Studies of Osteoporosis in Women of Puerto Rico
and South-easter Michigan ..." Clin Ortho 45:32, 1966
Mazees, R., "Bone Mineral Content of North Alaskan Eskimos", Journal of
Clinical Nutrition, 27:916, 1974
Ibid.
Ibid.
Nilas, L., "Calcium Supplementation and Postmenopausal Bone Loss,"
British Medical Journal, 289:1103, 1984
Recker, R., "The Effect of Milk Supplements on Calcium Metabolism, Bone
Metabolism and Calcium Balance," American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
41:254, 1985
Barzel, V., Osteoporosis, Grune and Stratton, New York, 1970

Dairy Trivia
QUESTIONS
1) What color is natural cheddar cheese?
2) If you were eating exactly the number of calories required to maintain
your present weight and then added one container of low-fat fruit yogurt
to your diet each day, how much weight would you
gain after one year?
3) For every quart of milk a cow produces, how much blood does she filter
through her udder?
4) Given the opportunity to rank order their beverage of choice (beer,
coffee, milk, soda, water, etc.), in what place did consumers rank milk?
5) Which contains more cholesterol? One quart of rich vanilla ice cream
or 68 slices of bacon?
6) Dairy industry sxperts recommend that adult Americans consume 1000 mg.
of calcium per day to prevent bone disease. What group of people consume
the most calcium in the world, 3500 mg.
per day, and what are their rates of osteoporosis?
ANSWERS
__________________________________________
{What color is natural cheddar cheese?}
1) White. Most people believe that cheddar is naturally orange. Actually,
cheddar becomes orange after the addition of a carrot-based food
coloring.
__________________________________________
{How much weight would you gain by eating a small container of low fat
yogurt each day for a year?}
2) 23 1/2 pounds.
One container of low-fat fruit yogurt contains 225 calories. There are
3500 calories in one pound of human fat. By eating 82,125 more calories
than your body required to maintain your current weight, you would gain
23 1/2 pounds in your hips, thighs, tummy and butt. So much for low fat
dairy foods
which naturally contain powerful bovine growth hormones.
__________________________________________
{For 1 quart of milk, how much blood is filtered through a cow's udder?}
3) A cow filters 500 quarts of blood for each quart of milk she produces.
Many people consider milk to be white blood. The average quart of milk
sold in America in the year 2000 contained 323 million
white blood cells.
__________________________________________
{How did consumers rate milk against other beverages?}
4) Milk ranked fifth as the beverage of choice among U.S. consumers. Soft
drinks led with a 30 percent share, followed by water at 17.3 percent,
beer at 12.4 percent, coffee at 10.5 percent, and milk at 10.4 percent.
All other beverages combined for the remaining 19.4%.
__________________________________________
(Which contains more cholesterol, one quart of ice cream or 68 slices of
bacon?}
5) This was a trick question. The quart of vanilla ice cream and the 68
slices of bacon contain the same amount of cholesterol.
__________________________________________
{What group of people eat 3500 mg per day of calcium, and what is the
effect?}
6) Inuit Indians (Eskimos) consume the highest per capita amount of
calcium in the world and most are crippled with debilitating bone disease
by age 40. Here's why:
http://www.notmilk.com/o.html
For more fun questions and answers, take the 25-question milk quiz:
http://www.notmilk.com/nmquiz.html
Robert Cohen
http://www.notmilk.com
201-967-7001

Subject: An American Recipe: Feces-Infused Milk
Yesterday (September 6, 2004), I reported that University of Minnesota
investigators had visited 110 dairy farms in four states and determined
that 92.7% of those farms tested positive for salmonella. See:
<http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/notmilk/message/1762 >
I was surprised by the angry responses from more than a dozen of my dairy
farmer readers. My columns sometimes make news within the milk industry,
and to a man, each of the pro-dairy readers objected to what they called
"the deceptive Notmilk newsletter." Their claim was that salmonella will
sometimes test positive in cows, but it is rare to detect salmonella or
other fecal bacteria in milk. Their claim was that once the milk is
collected, filtered, and picked up by the milk truck, it is clean and
wholesome.
I've got some very bad news for these hard working dairymen. The
September, 2004 issue of the Journal Dairy Science (Volume 87:2822-2830)
contains a study in which USDA researchers documented the presence of
fecal bacteria, including salmonella, in milk that had been loaded onto
refrigerated trucks.
Three government scientists (Van Kessel1, Karns, & Gorski) tested 861
bulk milk trucks in 21 states.
Coliform bacteria (bacteria originating in cow colons) were detected in
95% of the milk samples (818 of 860). Got dairy? Got feces! The milk may
be lily-white and appear to be pure, but there is nothing wholesome about
drinking a fluid tainted with fecal bacteria.
I've always wondered about this: If health inspectors detect the presence
of mouse turds in a vat of apple cider (an extremely rare event), the
entire batch is condemned. Yet, if those same inspectors were to detect
the presence of cow feces in cow's milk (it happens with every batch),
that same product is routinely packaged and distributed to consumers.
An American Recipe: Feces-Infused Milk
Ingredients:
Milk from one herd of dairy cows
Method:
Milk cows.
Collect and store milk in holding tank.
Filter milk. Discard filter with brown sludge.
<Note: That brown sludge ain't dirt.>
Load milk onto truck.
Put milk into containers.
Refrigerate.
Serve cold. With Brownies...
Robert Cohen
http://www.notmilk.com

Hu Loves Milk Too!
Hu Jintao is China's premier, and his promotion of milk and dairy
products will propel Chinese people
into a 21st century plagued by Western diseases. The Chinese have an
inferiority complex. They've seen the Japanese people grow an average of
two inches over the last two generations (40 years) while their heights
have remained stable. In order to attain the same physical growth, the
Chinese government has been working closely with America's dairy
industry, recognizing that growth hormones in milk are the missing link
keeping them from attaining the same stature as the Japanese.
What happened to Japan after World War II? Japanese got their first taste
of dairy products in 1946. While milk and dairy consumption increased by
twenty-one times, from 1950 to 1975, cerebral vascular disease (strokes)
increased 38 percent. Heart disease increased 35 percent, breast cancer
rates increased 77 percent. Colon cancer increased 77 percent. Lung
cancer increased by three hundred percent. In 2004, there is a runaway
asthma epidemic plaguing Japanese, and nobody seems to be considering the
increased cheese consumption.
What happened to young girls and the impact of milk consumption on
puberty is even more dramatic. In 1950 the average twelve-year old girl
was 4'6" tall and weighed 71 pounds. By 1975 the average Japanese girl,
after guzzling a daily diet of milk and dairy products containing 59
different bioactive hormones, had grown an average of 4 1/2 inches and
gained 19 pounds. In 1950 the average Japanese girl had her first
menstrual cycle at the age of 15.2 years. Twenty five years later, after
a daily intake of estrogen and progesterone from milk, the average
Japanese girl was ovulating at the age of 12.2 years, three years
younger.
The Chinese are developing enormous state-of-the-art 10,000-cow dairy
farms, but they do not have the same fully developed power and electrical
resources as do the Americans or Japanese. Refrigerators are not found in
every home. How to cool and store the milk? That problem has been solved.
The first Chinese-made fully automatic, milk packing equipment has been
manufactured by the Anhui Keyuan Group. They will now put the milk into
Parmalat-style shelf stable containers. Who will drink the half-pint
cartons? Children. The Chinese dairy industry has targeted kids. Their
method is to borrow another appropriately named American marketing tool,
Looney Tunes. Warner Brothers has developed a licensing deal with
Premier Hu Jintao so that milk cartons will include "fun-filled flavor"
for Chinese consumers.
I am a big fan of Chinese food. There are no cheese dishes to be found on
Chinese restaurant menus. One does not order Moo Shu dragon with
mozzarella cheese. I dread the thought of what happens when Porky
the stir-fried Pig meets Peking-Daffy Duck at Shanghai's new dairy bar.
Indigestion? Osteoporosis? Heart disease, asthma, and cancer? Choose one
from column A and one from column B. An American menu for western-style
diseases. One glass of milk and thirty minutes later, the Chinese will be
wanting more.

www.notmilk.com/kradjian.html
....this is an excellent article don't miss it! 
New Bone Study Shatters Dairy Lie
The October 21, 2004 issue of the International Journal of Osteoporosis
reports a "milk intake and fracture risk" study performed at the
University of Sheffield Medical School, United Kingdom, for the World
Health Organization. Researchers studied 28,300 women and 12,200 men and
determined:
"A low intake of calcium (less than 1 glass of milk daily) was not
associated with a significantly increased risk of any fracture,
osteoporotic fracture or hip fracture."
Scientists concluded:
"...[a] self-reported low intake of milk is not associated with any
marked increase in fracture risk and that the use of this risk indicator
is of little or no value in case-finding strategies."
This new publication is consistent with early studies, which reported:
"Calcium intake demonstrated no protective in preventing bone fractures.
In fact, those populations with the highest calcium intakes had higher
fracture rates than those with more modest calcium intakes."
Calif Tissue Int 1992;50
"There is no significant association between teenaged milk consumption
and the risk of adult fractures. Data indicate that frequent milk
consumption and higher dietary calcium intakes in middle aged women do
not provide protection against hip or forearm fractures...women consuming
greater amounts of calcium from dairy foods had significantly increased
risks of hip fractures, while no increase in fracture risk was observed
for the same levels of calcium from nondairy sources."
12-year Harvard study of 78,000 women American Journal of Public Health
1997;87
Robert Cohen
http://www.notmilk.com

'Good' Bacteria Help with Eczema in Infants
Fri Apr 8, 6:51 PM ET
Health - Reuters
NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Mixing a type of beneficial or "probiotic"
bacteria, Lactobacillus GG (LGG), into food helps reduce symptoms in
allergic infants with the skin condition eczema, according to a report in
the medical journal Allergy.
Previous reports have suggested that probiotic bacteria may be useful in
reducing symptoms in food-allergic children. To investigate this further,
Dr. Mirva Viljanen, from the University of Helsinki in Finland, and
colleagues assessed symptoms in 230 infants with eczema and suspected
allergy to cow's milk. The children's food was mixed with capsules
containing LGG alone, LGG plus three other probiotics, or inactive
"placebo" for 4 weeks.
Following the treatment phase, milk exposure testing was performed and
cow's milk allergy was diagnosed in 120 infants, the authors report. In
the overall analysis, allergy symptoms dropped by 65 percent during the
study, but no differences were observed between the treatment groups.
However, when the analysis was confined to subjects sensitized by a type
of antibody called IgE, LGG alone, but not with the other probiotics,
seemed to reduce symptoms compared with placebo.
Influencing the natural microbes in the intestinal tract "by
administration of probiotic bacteria to treat allergy is a new
alternative," the authors state. The findings suggest that this may be a
successful approach for some children with food allergy.
SOURCE: Allergy, April 2005.

One of my readers recently wrote to me and asked, "What Notmilk column are
you most proud of? I've been reading your notmilkisms for years. Just out of
curiosity, which one is your personal favorite of all time?"
I had to give that query quite a bit of thought. During a ten year period, I
wrote and posted a column nearly every day. They now number over 3,000.
Which one is numero uno on my list?
It did not take long for me to come up with an appropriate non-controversial
response. The best one was...is...by far:
Today's!
<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
If Ignorance Was Bliss..
If ignorance had been bliss, then we would not be familiar with the work of
endocrinologist Clark Grosvenor. Having nothing better to do on a Sunday
afternoon, many of us real men*** might have turned on a ball game or
figured out the Final Four college basketball teams, working backwards into
selecting
each round of survivors in the upcoming NCAA March Madness tourney.
Clark Grosvenor was a man driven by curiousity and had a burning desire to
know if hormones could possibly be found in the same glass of cow's milk
that school kids drink. Dairy farmers might have suggested that Dr.
Grosvenor was a scientist badly in need of a hobby.
So, Grosvenor got funding for his project and he went to the lab. And he
researched. And he used all of the skills that we laymen have long since
forgotten from high school chemistry to isolate and identify. And when Dr.
Grosvenor had finished his astounding task, he had done just that. Isolated
and identified. Fifty-nine unique hormones in every sip of milk. A motto
never to be used by the dairy industry's copywriters and admen, and you can
bet your sweet bippy or your bottom dollar on that one.
The Heinz company would have been proud to own such a motto. The dairy
industry would be mortified. This information could never be released to the
public. Who would ever drink milk after learning that tidbit of information?
With that knowledge, what parent would ever allow a child to drink cow's
milk? Despite the odds against him, Grosvenor set off to find a publisher
for his mind-boggling research results.
Rumor has it that Time and Newsweek passed and Ladies Home Journal could not
justify publishing Grosvenor's research because of its incompatibility with
the seventeen milk ads that were due to run concurrently in the following
month's edition. Sport's Illustrated saw no point to it all, but their
editors did note that models posing for the swimsuit issue kept showing up
with physical endowments more enhanced than previous years. Even the New
York Times, with all the news that's fit to print, determined that this news
was not fit to print, recognizing that truth must subordinate itself to ad
revenue. Ultimately, Grosvenor's work was published in volume 14,
number 6 of an obscure publication called the Journal of Endocrine Reviews
in 1992, where it sat for many years, undiscovered, until a guy calling
himself the NotMilkMan found the paper, and in the vererable style of
Archimedes some 22 centuries earlier, uttered his solitary word of
effervescing acknowledgment, "Eureka!"
Visualize a wretched looking emaciated cow with flies buzzing round her
stinking butt and grotesquely contoured head. Now, imagine the most
beautiful Holstein specimen, with anatomically perfect udders laden with
milk. Both bovines share a common distinction. Each one carries milk, which
naturally contains powerful steroid hormones. Now, ladies and gentlemen,
glance over at the serene and lovely face of your mate. He or she is about
to wake from a restless night's sleep and drink that glass of milk from
either creature for breakfast and become transformed into a psycho-beast
from the netherworld and
there's not a gosh-darned thing that can be done about it.
Cow's milk contains steroid and protein hormones. The healthiest milk from
the cleanest, organically-raised cow unquestionably contains
hormones. The ugliest cow, barely able to stand on her own four feet,
suffering from the agony of arthritic legs caused by calcium depletion, in
constant anguish from overworked and ulcerated udders also carries milk
containing these same naturally occurring powerful hormones.
Can you imagine starting your day with an estrogen pill, followed by
progesterone, prolactin, melatonin, oxytocin, and 50+ other chemical
messengers, including gastrointestinal peptides and hypothalamic hormones?
It is no wonder that the Townsend Medical Letter noted the following
in May of 1995:
"In reality, cow's milk, especially processed cow's milk, has been linked to
a variety of health problems, including: ...mood swings, depression, and
irritability."
OK, trust me here, people...Due to circumstances far beyond our control, we
have become behavioral experts on this hormonal thing...pre-menstrual,
post-menstrual, climacteric, this syndrome and that...how can we cope with
this stuff? Our crimes? So we occasionally leave the toilet seat in the
wrong position and drop dirty underwear on the bedroom floor...is this
reason enough to be living with a hormonal psycho-creature from perdition?
If your significant other has eaten one or more portions of dairy before
bed, let this be your warning. Be nice, be caring, don't, I repeat, don't
push the wrong buttons. You know the obvious triggers, but you may not be
aware of the explosive force of dairy synergy caused by swallowing hormones.
Milk hormones.
For fatal attractions, do not turn the light off on your dairy-using mate
until you hear the snoring. It ain't over until the neurotic dairy-user
sleeps. Allow your
mate to drink milk and you've taken the first step towards attaining your
inevitable destiny, that of a pathetically beaten lost soul. It's not too
late to spike the Special-K with soymilk. If you do not, prepare to suffer
the consequences... His name was Vinko Bogataj, and he forever became
known as the "agony of defeat" week after week, year after year, as ABC'S
Wide World of Sports captured the losing end of his now infamous ski jump.
The agony of defeat: <http://tinyurl.com/2vzo85>
That is you, my friend. You are Vinko, and the mood swings, depression, and
irritability described so eloquently by medical professionals writing for
the Townsend Medical Letter and suffered so ignominiously by your mate after
consuming milk and dairy products will continue to take you on an
upside-down inside-out somersault through life.
Real Man Test*** <http://tinyurl.com/3xp3n2>
<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
Learn to tell this joke...it's worth five points on the "real men test"
which you just skipped over... see question number five.
<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
A man goes to a medical clinic for tests, and the doctor says, "I've got bad
news, and more bad news."
"Okay doc, give it to me straight. What's wrong?"
"The bad news is...you've gotten prostate cancer from your habit of drinking
cow's milk and eating cheese."
"And the other bad news?"
"The other bad news is, you've caught Mad Cow Disease and gotten Alzheimers
by consuming dairy products."
"Well, at least I don't have cancer!"
Robert Cohen
http://www.notmilk.com
i4crob@earthlink.net

Back to page
|
|